摘要
[目的/意义]为了解决CSSCI来源期刊评价中评价指标可能存在的人为操纵,以及办刊时间过短导致的不公平问题,文章提出了一种新的基于防止人为操纵与评价指标变权的评价方法。[方法/过程]首先,对期刊过度自引和载文量偏低进行适当修正,得到合理影响因子。然后,根据办刊历史对总被引频次权重进行变权,当优秀期刊累计载文量偏低时,对影响因子的权重也进行变权修正。[结果/结论]基于图书馆、情报与文献学学科的CSSCI来源期刊在中国知网CNKI引文数据库的研究结果表明,存在一定程度的期刊过度自引与人为操纵载文量的现象。通过对传统CSSCI来源期刊评价方法进行改进,文章提出的CSSCI评价结果与传统CSSCI评价结果差异较大,更加凸显了新评价方法的重要性。
[Purpose/significancce]In order to solve the possible human manipulation of evaluation indicators in the evaluation of CSSCI journals and the unfairness caused by too short publication time,this paper proposes a new evaluation method based on preventing human manipulation and changing the weight of evaluation indicators.[Method/process]Firstly,correct the journal's excessive self-citation and make appropriate corrections to the low number of articles to obtain a reasonable impact factor.Then change the weight of the total citation frequency according to the history of the journal,and change the weight of the impact factor when the cumulative number of articles in the outstanding journals is low.[Result/conclusion]Based on the research results of the CSSCI journals of Library Information and Documentation in CNKI Citation Database,the phenomenon of excessive self-citation and man-made manipulation of the content of the journals exists to a certain extent.The traditional CSSCI journal evaluation methods need to be improved,the new CSSCI evaluation results are quite different from the traditional CSSCI evaluation results,highlighting the importance of the new evaluation method.
作者
俞立平
陈坚
YU Liping;CHEN Jian(School of statistics and mathematics,Zhejiang Gongshang University,Hangzhou 310018;Management School,Yangzhou Polytechnic College,Yangzhou 225009)
出处
《科技情报研究》
CSSCI
2024年第1期22-32,共11页
Scientific Information Research
基金
浙江省自然科学基金重点项目“制造业从数量型创新向质量型创新转型机制研究”(编号:Z21G030004)
江苏省教育科学规划重点项目“高职院校混合所有制办学机制创新的理论与实践研究”(编号:B/2022/02/82)
湖南省2021年湖湘高层次人才聚集工程创新团队(编号:2021RC5029)。
