摘要
【目的】考察出版单位编辑学论文的发表情况,从而探讨出版单位编辑学研究水平与其办刊质量的关系。【方法】检索CNKI数据库2012—2014年《中国科技期刊研究》和《编辑学报》的文章,对参与发文的期刊出版单位的发文量进行统计和排序,得出发文量排名前10的单位,另外抽样只参与发表1篇论文的期刊出版单位,对二者办刊质量的相关指标,包括拥有期刊数、国内外重要数据库收录情况、影响因子变化、复合总被引频次、复合即年指标、Web即年下载率和总下载频次等进行比较分析。【结果】在这两刊上参与发表编辑学论文较多、编辑学研究水平较高的单位大部分旗下拥有多种期刊,有较多期刊被国内外重要数据库收录,并且旗下大部分期刊近两年的影响因子处于上升趋势,相关评价指标均优于发文较少的单位。【结论】出版单位开展编辑学研究活动可以促进编辑水平提高,促进出版单位建设,促进期刊外部发展环境优化,最终共同促进办刊质量提高。
[ Purposes] This study is to investigate the correlation between publishing quality and editorial research of journal editorial departments. [Methods] By searching the CNKI database, the number of published papers form Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals and Acta Editologica from 2012 to 2014 is obtained. Journal editorial departments are sorted by the number of editorial research papers they participated in. The top 10 departments publishing editorial papers are obtained as one group, and those departments only have one editorial research paper are selected by random sampling, as the other group. The number, the index information, the changes of impact factor, composite total citations, composite immediacy index, Web download rate and total download rate of journals published by those editorial departments are compared between 2 groups. [ Findings ] Journal editorial departments which have more editorial papers develop better, possess more journals, and have more journals indexed by important databases, compared with departments which have less papers. And growth rates of impact factor and other journal evaluation indexes of departments with more papers are prior to those with less papers. [ Conclusions ] It is important for the journal editorial department to participate in editorial research, which can promote the editing level, enhance the construction of the editorial department, facilitate the environment of the journal market, and finally elevate the publishing quality.
出处
《中国科技期刊研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2015年第9期981-986,共6页
Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals
关键词
编辑学研究
科技期刊
编辑学研究论文
办刊质量
Editorial research
Scientific journals
Editorial research paper
Publishing quality
