非内国仲裁裁决的理论与实证论析被引量：15

Theoretical and Empirical Study on the Non-Domestic Arbitral Awards

导出

摘要 "非内国仲裁裁决"是 1958 年《纽约公约》第 1 条第 1 款中规定的涵盖于《纽约公约》适用范围的一类裁决。由于《纽约公约》自身并未对该类裁决的性质及认定标准作出具体规定,长期以来,国际商事仲裁理论和实践关于"非内国仲裁裁决"问题一直存有争议。本文从国际商事仲裁的基本理论和《纽约公约》的具体规定出发,厘清了将此类裁决认定为"非内国裁决"的合理性,以及对其予以承认和执行的理论依据。但是,单纯的学理建议并不能解决我国实践中所面临的困境,只有法律制度的规定及最高人民法院的相关司法解释才能使"非内国裁决"在我国的认定和执行真正走向清晰化。 Non - domestic arbitral awards is a type of awards that applies to 1958 New York Convention in accordance with Article 1.1 of the Convention. Due to the fact that the Convention has not formulated definite character and standards of non - domestic arbitral awards, such awards have always been controversial both in international commercial arbitration theory and practice for a long time. Based on the fundamental theory of international commercial arbitration and specific provisions of the New York Convention, the article holds that it is reasonable and logical to consider such arbitral awards to be ＂non - domestic arbitral awards＂, as well as recognize and enforce them. However, it is far from enough to solve the practical problems by theories. Instead, legislation and judicial interpretation of Supreme Court are required to clear the air on recognition and enforcement of non -domestic arbitral awards in China.

作者刘晓红

机构地区华东政法大学

出处《法学杂志》 CSSCI 北大核心 2013年第5期77-87,共11页 Law Science Magazine

基金 2011年度国家社会科学基金项目(编号:11BFX143)的阶段性成果

关键词《纽约公约》仲裁裁决国籍非内国仲裁裁决无国籍裁决 New York Convention nationality of arbitral awards non - domestic arbitral awards stateless awards

分类号 D997.4 [政治法律—国际法学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献28

1宋连斌,董海洲.国际商会仲裁裁决国籍研究——从最高人民法院的一份复函谈起[J].北京科技大学学报（社会科学版）,2009,25(3):46-54. 被引量：23
2王天红.《国际商事仲裁裁决的国籍确定》,载《人民法院报》2007年1月23日第6版.
3赵秀文.《国际商事仲裁及其法律适用研究》[M].北京大学出版社,2002年版.第32-40页.
4赵秀文.非内国裁决的法律性质辨析[J].法学,2007(10):16-23. 被引量：15
5Albert Jan Van Den Berg, When is an arbitral award nondomestic under the New York Convention of 1958, Pace Law Review, Volume 6, issue 1,Fall 1985.
6Albert Jan van den Berg, The New York Convention of 1958. An Overview, http .//www. arbitration - icca. orb/media/0/12125884227980/new_york_convention of 1958_overview. pdf,访问日期.2012年12月10日.
7Bergesen v. Joseph Muller Corp. , 710 F. 2d 928 (2d Cir. 1983).
8Albert Jan Van Den Berg, When is an arbitral award nondomestic under the New York Convention of 1958, Pace Law Review, Volunle 6, issue 1 ,Fall 1985.
9Albert Jan van den Berg, The New York Convention of 1958. An Overview, http .//www. arbitration - ieca. org/media/0/12125884227980/new_york_convention of 1958_overview. pdf,访问日期.2012年12月10日.
10http.//www, uncitral, org/uncitral/en/uncitral_texts/arbitration/NYConven-tion.html,访问日期.2012年12月10日.