著作权合理使用制度之正当性研究被引量：96

Justification of Fair Use of Copyright

下载PDF

导出

摘要著作权"合理使用"制度是各国著作权制度中对著作权限制的主要内容。合理使用制度体现了著作权法保护作者和其他著作权人的利益与促进知识与信息广泛传播的双重目的。合理使用的正当性可以从多方面加以认识,包括激励与接近之平衡、宪法与公共利益、以交易成本和古典经济学为基础的经济学分析等。在网络环境下,著作权合理使用制度仍然有其存在的合理性。我国颁布实施的《信息网络传播权保护条例》对合理使用的规定即是这种体现。 Fair use is a main way to limit copyright in the copyright regime in all states, which intends to pursue double aims of protecting the interest of the author and other copyright owners and encouraging a wide spread of knowledge and information. The justification of fair use can be understood in different aspects, including balance of stimulation and access, constitution law and public interest, economic analyses based on transactional cost and classic economics. Even in the context of network, the existence of fair use can be justified. The fair use provision in the Regulations of Protection of Dissemination of Information in Networks enacted and enforced in China is such a good example.

作者冯晓青

机构地区中国政法大学

出处《现代法学》 CSSCI 北大核心 2009年第4期29-41,共13页 Modern Law Science

关键词著作权合理使用正当性公共利益 copyright fair use justification public interest

分类号 D923.41 [政治法律—民商法学] D923.4 [政治法律—民商法学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献20

1Glynn S.Lunney,Reexamine Copyright Incentive Access Paradigm,49 Vanderbilt Law Review 500(1996).
2Harry N.Rosenfield,Constitutional Aspects of Fair Use in Copyright Law,50 Notre Dame Lawyer 790(1975).
3Hudon,The Copyright Period:Weighing Personal Against Public Interest,49 A.B.A.J.759(1963).
4Robert A.Kreiss,Accessibility and Commereialization in Copyright Theory.43 UCLA L.REV,13-14(1995).
5Neil Weinstock Netanel,Copyright and Democratic Civil Society,106 Yale L.Rev.L.J.283,306-14(1996).
6Stephen M.Mcjhohn,Fair Use and the Privitalization of Copyright,35 San Diego Law Bedew 61(1998).
7Maureen Ryan,Cyberspace as Public Space:A Public Trust Paradigm for Copyright in a Digital World,79 Oregon Law Review 647(2000).
8American Geophysical Union,60 F.3d at 930 n.8;Richard P.Adelstein and Steven I.Peretz,The Competition of Technologies in Markets for Ideas:Copyright and Fair Use in Evolutionary Perspective.5 Intl.Rev.L.& Econ.209,230-33(1985).
9Pierre N.Leval,Ninmmer Lectu re:Fair Use Rescued,44 UCLA Law Review 1456(1997).
10Benjamin R.Kuhn,A Dilemma in Cyberspace and Beyond:Copyright Law for Intellectual Property Distributed Over the Information Superhighways of Today and Tomorrow,10Temp.Int'1.& Comp.L.J.171(1996).

二级参考文献22

1[英]坎南编.《关于法律、警察、岁入及军备的演讲》.陈福生,陈振骅译.商务印书馆,1962年版，第260页
2Adam Smith, Lectures on Jurisprudence; Report of 1762 - 63, in Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nnations 754 n. 69 (1776).
3Information Infrastructure Task Force, Intellectual Property and the Natinal Information Infrastructure: The Report of the Working Group On Intellectual Property Rights7, 14 (1995).
4Mazer v. Stein 347 U.S. 201, 219 (1954)
5Rockford Map Publishers v. Directory Serv. Co. of Colo, 768 F. 2d 145, 148 (7th Cir. 1985)476
6U.S. 1061 (1986).
7Stewart v. Abend, 495 U.S. 207, 228 29 (1990).
817 U.S.C. 106- 106A (1994).
9National Business Lists, Inc. v. Dun & Bradstreet, Inc, 552 F. Supp. 89 (N. D. Ⅲ. 1982)
10Squires, Copyright and Compilations in the Computer Era: Old Wine in New Bottles, 24 BULL. COPYRIGHT SOC' Y U.S.A. 18, 44 - 45 (1977).